Sadly I was informed last week by a person that sells perfume and has been doing it for many years that the Bellodgia customer is dying off. It’s time to make new fans, so here’s my review 🙂
The EDT of Bellodgia smells like carnation vanilla ice cream. It’s a creamy carnation with hints of “green” rose with violet and balsamic vanilla. The green in the EDT is a very pleasant edition and you won’t find it in the other concentrations of Bellodgia. The heart is a spicy floral with a nutty vanilla. The dry-down is a subtler version of the heart.
I’m sure the vintage Bellodgia is gorgeous. But, I think the current Bellodgia is rather nice. Why? Because I prefer the “lighter” EDT. I’m not looking for the Bellodgia draped in a cloak of fur. I rather like this one with its green notes mixed with the spicy florals. It’s showing some skin. I actually prefer the EDT over the EDP or the extrait.
Notes listed include carnation, sandalwood and vanilla. Launch date 1927 (reviewing modern). PERFUMER – Ernest Daltroff (don’t know who reformulated it)
Give Bellodgia a try if you are looking for a carnation perfume that isn’t too spicy. Try it if you like CdG Series 2 Red Carnation, Serge Lutens Vitriol d’oeillet, Dolce & Gabbana Velvet Love and/or Jean Paul Gaultier Classique EDT. I really can’t see how anyone can sniff the new Bellodgia EDT and think it smells “old fashioned”. But, I’m biased. I like this stuff.
The EDT has average projection and below average longevity. I get about 3-4 hours of wear from it.
The EDT of Bellodgia can be found at Caron boutiques. You can also find it discounted on Fragrancenet.
Victoria’s Final EauPINION – Carnation vanilla ice cream. I love it. It needs more fans.
Want more reviews? Try…
Just found a sample of CdG Red Carnation yesterday that I didn’t even remember ordering. I quite liked it, though it didn’t seem to last very long on me.
Must find my sample of Bellodgia and revisit it, though I think it didn’t wow me.
That’s my complaint with CdG Carnation.
Try again. Concentration makes a different too with the Carons.
I love the vintage Bellodgia. I haven’t tried the new one, though. I think the vintage managed to make a big, heavy, film noir show out of a flower with a humble reputation, and that’s awesome!
Joan recently posted..Felanilla by Parfumerie Generale
Vintage is gorgeous. Much bigger, bolder and with more meat on its bones 🙂
Dear Victoria
Being something of a Caron man – I must say that I’m a fan of Bellodgia in all the concentrations.
The extrait is as you so beautifully put it ‘a cloak of fur’, but sometimes when the weather is as it has been of here late that’s just what one needs.
You’re quite right, there is a green element in the EdT that gives it a vibrancy, an esprit de corps that the other concentrations are too indulgently languid to aspire to.
But have you tried applying the EdT on top of the parfum? Oh yes!
This is of course how Caron’s were designed to be used, and it certainly shows.
As for the reformulation, I think it may be the work of the house parfumeur in residence Richard Fraysse, though in structure it seems to differ from some of his other work.
Now, I will stop babbling on, it’s just that when the subject of Caron comes up, the Dandy is away!!
Thank you as ever for the thoughtful and always accurate review.
Yours ever
The Perfumed Dandy
theperfumeddandy recently posted..She knows her own mind… Knowing by Estee Lauder The Perfumed Dandy’s Scented Letter
Why didn’t I think of layering those? It makes perfect sense. The lovely base of the parfum with the greenness of the EDT…
I understand your passion. I’m a Caron fan girl. Sometimes I’m amazed that I dare to wear anything else.
Hi,
I just came across this post. I was very amused to read that someone had said that ” the Bellodgia customer is dying off”!! I have been wearing Bellodgia since I was a teenager – in the late 60s – I am 62 now. Ah, the foolishness of extreme youth….
Wasn’t that one heck of a thing to say to someone wanting to buy Bellodgia? I was wondering if she was trying to put a curse on me 😉
It’s a gorgeous perfume. And oddly enough, I think it’s modern enough for today. To me, it’s not “dated”. True beauty never goes out of style!
[…] EauMG – The 1920’s are going to be a big trend this year thanks to The Great Gatsby movie coming out this spring. Instead of trying a perfume inspired by flappers, try one actually worn by flappers! Victoria reviews her favorite carnation perfume. […]
[…] EauMG – The 1920’s are going to be a big trend this year thanks to The Great Gatsby movie coming out this spring. Instead of trying a perfume inspired by flappers, try one actually worn by flappers! Victoria reviews her favorite carnation perfume. […]
[…] EauMG – The 1920’s are going to be a big trend this year thanks to The Great Gatsby movie coming out this spring. Instead of trying a perfume inspired by flappers, try one actually worn by flappers! Victoria reviews her favorite carnation perfume. […]
[…] EauMG – The 1920’s are going to be a big trend this year thanks to The Great Gatsby movie coming out this spring. Instead of trying a perfume inspired by flappers, try one actually worn by flappers! Victoria reviews her favorite carnation perfume. […]
[…] EauMG – The 1920’s are going to be a big trend this year thanks to The Great Gatsby movie coming out this spring. Instead of trying a perfume inspired by flappers, try one actually worn by flappers! Victoria reviews her favorite carnation perfume. […]
[…] EauMG – The 1920’s are going to be a big trend this year thanks to The Great Gatsby movie coming out this spring. Instead of trying a perfume inspired by flappers, try one actually worn by flappers! Victoria reviews her favorite carnation perfume. […]
[…] love this perfume. I call it “carnation vanilla ice cream” (full review here). It contains vanilla and carnation but isn’t too heavy for summer […]
[…] carnation from the 1920′s. I say spend all of your money on the perfume part of your costume Full review. Retails for $180 at […]
[…] Lily if you like spicy florientals. Or if you like perfumes like YSL Opium, Amouage Honour Woman, Caron Bellodogia, Serge Lutens Vitriol d’Oeillet, Estee Lauder Cinnabar and/or Penhaligon’s Lily & […]
[…] Guerlain Shalimar still smells plush in comparison to what else is sold in department stores. Caron Bellodogia is not the same but it still smells good. Now, Chanel No. 5 is a complete and total joke in […]
[…] Flora a try if you like carnation. Or if you like perfumes like Caron Bellodogia parfum, Lush Flower Market, Cartier, Les Heures de Cartier L’Heure Convoiteé II, Strange […]
[…] a carnation that isn’t too spicy (DSH Perfumes Oeillets Rouges); nor, is it powdery (Caron Bellodogia). It’s a fresh carnation that showcases the spiciness, the greenness and the floralness of […]
[…] & Plenty candies. It’s has that “carnation ice cream” thing going on that Caron Bellodogia does. It’s sweet, but it’s not a gourmand. Apre l’Ondee lives up to its name, […]